The Hot Zone
China's newly announced air defense identification zone over the East China Sea aims to shore up national security
Current Issue
· Table of Contents
· Editor's Desk
· Previous Issues
· Subscribe to Mag
Subscribe Now >>
Expert's View
Market Watch
North American Report
Government Documents
Expat's Eye
Photo Gallery
Reader's Service
Learning with
'Beijing Review'
E-mail us
RSS Feeds
PDF Edition
Reader's Letters
Make Beijing Review your homepage
Hot Links

cheap eyeglasses
Market Avenue

UPDATED: April 3, 2010 NO. 14 APRIL 8, 2010
Playing the Blame Game
A possible China-U.S. trade and currency war will be harmful to both countries and even the world economy



April 15 marks a crucial deadline for Sino-U.S. relations—the U.S. Department of Treasury will make its final decision on labeling China as a "currency manipulator" that day. The prospect of a trade war, or even worse, a currency war, between two of the largest economies in the world has cast a shadow over the still unstable global economy.

The United States threatens economic sanctions on China, which makes the exchange rate issue even more complicated.

A serious, cool-headed calculation of the risks must first be thoroughly considered, for if such an economically detrimental situation comes, both China and the United States will lose, leaving the global economy severely damaged.

Scapegoating the yuan


ON THE HILL: U.S. Senator Charles Schumer speaks about the renminbi exchange rate on March 16 (XINHUA) 

Why does the United States continue to pressure China to appreciate its currency—the yuan? And what are the chances of this pressure turning into action? U.S. domestic politics and recent diplomatic frictions between the two countries can help answer these questions.

As the U.S. mid-term elections approach, weakening political support for the Democratic party and President Barack Obama is beginning to show. It has become a grim challenge to maintain its current majority after the upcoming election. In order to gain political credit, advisors are obviously turning to a recent political practice in times of crisis, which is to blame China. Toughening the stance against China is conducive to divert popular dissatisfaction about Obama's economic policies; and taking actions on the yuan will boost the hopes of those voters who are complaining about high unemployment.

Fear is proliferating across the United States due to China's rapid economic growth, making it ideal for American politicians to implement policies that "take on" China. To reap immediate benefits, pressuring China's exchange rate was meant to win the support of "swing states" and their representatives in the Congress during the healthcare debate.

The threat of sanctions on Chinese goods could be useful to saving "face" following the recent bilateral diplomatic squabble over the U.S. arms sales to Taiwan and Obama's meeting with the Dalai Lama.

The U.S. Government tends to follow precedents of the past, with Chinese actions labeled "arrogant" or "tough." This friction is related to changes in the relative power position between the two countries in the wake of the global financial crisis, as the United States tries to let China know it is still the No.1.

Harming global economy

Since July 2005, China's currency, also known as renminbi (yuan), has appreciated up to 21 percent. But against American expectations it has not helped to improve the U.S. trade deficit. And China's trade surplus has not reduced.

Clearly, the shaping forces of today's exchange rate have gone far beyond bilateral trade. Doubts persist surrounding the effects the yuan appreciation will have on China's status as the "workshop of the world" or the boost it is expected to give American exports.

The Chinese economy will without doubt suffer damage from forced economic actions. First of all, 20 percent or more of the surcharge tariff will drive a large share of Chinese exports out of the U.S. market and will significantly reduce external demands.

Second, a large number of workers in China's export processing zones will lose jobs, resulting in a slowdown of economic growth and social unrest.

Third, as more speculative capital enters China betting on the yuan appreciation, the asset bubble problem in China's economy will deteriorate and possibly spiral out of control.

A possible Sino-U.S. trade and currency war will strike a severe blow to East Asia's economy as a whole. The so-called "Made-in-China" miracle has actually been a collective of division of labor across the region. In the past 15 years, East Asian economies including Japan, South Korea, Singapore, China's Taiwan and Hong Kong moved their assembly lines to China's mainland to take advantage of its cheap labor costs, and continue to target their exports on the U.S. market.

These economies greatly reduced their trade surpluses with the United States. But it is China who takes the blame for creating the surplus. We can easily imagine the panic and damage that will ensue in East Asia regarding even the slightest possibility of a trade and currency war between these two giants.

A major setback will be caused to the faltering recovery of the global economy, too. Leading the world out of the recession, China has replaced the United States as the greatest engine of the economic growth. But the outbreak of a Sino-U.S. economic war will only lead to global economic turmoil.

1   2   Next  

Top Story
-Protecting Ocean Rights
-Partners in Defense
-Fighting HIV+'s Stigma
-HIV: Privacy VS. Protection
-Setting the Tone
Most Popular
About BEIJINGREVIEW | About beijingreview.com | Rss Feeds | Contact us | Advertising | Subscribe & Service | Make Beijing Review your homepage
Copyright Beijing Review All right reserved