Lifestyle
Is it time to cancel GDP growth targets?
  ·  2021-02-09  ·   Source: NO.7-8 FEBRUARY 18, 2021
 
LI SHIGONG

At a recent high-level economic symposium, the question of whether or not countries should set GDP growth targets became a hot topic of debate. Some economists pointed out that all of the world's developed countries and the majority of middle-income countries have abandoned GDP growth rates as a target of macroeconomic control. Should China follow suit?The practice of using GDP as a key measure of economic development is not flawless, and some experts therefore suggest it be abandoned. However, others believe the GDP index still has a role to play in China's economy, that doing away with it would impact wide-ranging aspects of Chinese society, and that identifying a substitute index is problematic.

Ma Jun (finance.sina.com.cn): At the beginning of 2020, due to uncertainties caused by the novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19), China gave up the usual practice of setting up a GDP growth target for the year. In my opinion, the target should be permanently abolished. Rates of employment and control of inflation should be used as the major targets of macroeconomic policy. GDP numbers can still be used to forecast financial revenue and expenditure by financial departments, and investment agencies can employ these numbers as a reference for investment decisions. However, by no means should GDP growth rate be used as a major index to measure local officials' achievements in governance.

Several issues are haunting the use of GDP growth targets. If it is an official target, local governments usually tend to set higher targets for lower levels of government, possibly raising financial risk-taking, as the easiest way to promote the GDP growth rate is to borrow money. Additionally, when GDP is used as the major measure of governments' performance, some local governments may falsely inflate local economic data. To use employment rates and control of inflation as the major targets of macroeconomic control is a common practice in market economies around the world. It's time to consider this also in China.

Wang Wenjing (m.hexun.com): GDP growth targets should not be totally eradicated, however, the index needs to be improved. Historically, GDP growth target has played a big role in stimulating China's rapid economic expansion. Thanks to GDP targets, local officials are encouraged to try their best to develop their local economies, which is a crucial reason the Chinese economy is moving forward so rapidly and Chinese people's incomes are increasing so fast. To some extent, the sharply rising GDP growth rate is also raising the Chinese people' confidence in the country.

Of course, GDP is not a perfect index to measure a country's overall economic situation. It fails to indicate the efficiency of the economy, it covers up pollution, and it does not reflect the true picture of people's livelihoods.

At the current stage, many problems still need to be resolved in the process of China's economic development, and we still need our economy to develop at a relatively high speed. Therefore, GDP growth targets should not be axed but should be supplemented by other indexes such as efficiency, pollution and livelihoods.

Bao Dike (m.hexun.com): It's the perfect time and a reasonable idea to abolish GDP growth targets.

GDP reflects newly increased social wealth and the basic material foundation that sustains overall social operation. When a society is in dire need of material wealth, it is necessary to set up this kind of growth target, otherwise the overall economy will be susceptible to disruption by sudden headwinds. Once the economy has already reached a certain level of material wealth, even if GDP remains the same or drops a little due to unexpected factors, the overall economy will not be seriously disrupted.

Increasing GDP can be compared to baking a large cake, once the cake reaches a certain size, dividing it and distributing it become just as difficult as creating it. 

Copyedited by Garth Wilson

Comments to panxiaoqiao@bjreview.com

China
Opinion
World
Business
Lifestyle
Video
Multimedia
 
China Focus
Documents
Special Reports
 
About Us
Contact Us
Advertise with Us
Subscribe
Partners: China.org.cn   |   China Today   |   China Pictorial   |   People's Daily Online   |   Women of China   |   Xinhua News Agency   |   China Daily
CGTN   |   China Tibet Online   |   China Radio International   |   Global Times   |   Qiushi Journal
Copyright Beijing Review All rights reserved 京ICP备08005356号 京公网安备110102005860