Failing to Get Its Act Together
U.S. unable to devise national strategy even after lesson from China
By Sherry Qin  ·  2020-03-20  ·   Source: NO.13 MARCH 26, 2020
Shoppers queue ahead of the opening of a Costco wholesale store in Los Angeles, the U.S., on March 14 in a bid to stock up on essential food and household items amid the coronavirus pandemic (XINHUA)

As the novel coronavirus situation in the U.S. worsens, President Donald Trump's March 16 tweet calling the virus "Chinese virus" inflamed an already rampant xenophobic sentiment in the country. The racist tweet put the large Asian community in a dangerous position, and experts warned that racism could hamper the global efforts to curb the spread of the disease.

"During the swine flu epidemic of 2009 in California, a lot more people died, but there was no demonization of Californians or Americans," Joan Kaufman, former associate professor of health policy and management at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health, said.

Wan Yang, an epidemiologist at Columbia University, warned that racism will discourage people with early-stage mild symptoms to seek testing and treatment. "We want people to feel comfortable to talk to their doctors when they do have symptoms, so we can get cases isolated, treated and stop the transmission as early as possible," Yang said.

The Trump administration is increasingly criticized for taking few stringent actions to contain the spread of the coronavirus except for the racist and fallacious blame. A growing number of politicians and epidemiologists are calling for action from the federal government to centralize resources and maximize the physical capacity to battle against the coronavirus.

Zhuoxuan Tian, a Chinese student, has witnessed the coronavirus containment measures both in China and the U.S. She visited her family in Beijing during the Chinese New Year in January and then returned to New York to continue her study. She said ordinary American people "don't have adequate knowledge" about the seriousness of the virus and "the harm it can cause" as a result of "the government's sluggish guidance in terms of the nature of this virus."

Yuting, a Chinese national who works in Chicago and declined to give her last name, booked her flight back to China as soon as her manager approved her leave of absence. "I travel by plane every week for my work and am exposed to a large number of travelers. Some of them may have contracted the virus but didn't know yet," she said. "They might not even think about getting tested and treat the symptoms just as normal flu."

Yuting said she feels bitterly disappointed that "the sacrifices that China made and precautions that Asians took are not appreciated, and even condemned."

National effort needed

In a letter addressed to Trump on March 15, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo said, "Every country affected by this crisis has handled it on a national basis. The United States has not."

As more cases are identified, states will inevitably face an overflow of contagious patients and shortage of hospital beds. In New York, the state with the most confirmed cases in the U.S., there are 214 hospitals with 53,470 beds, only 3,186 of which are intensive-care beds, according to official data. If the outbreak peaks in 45 days, based on epidemiologists' projection, the U.S. will need 55,000 to 110,000 hospital beds.

Bruce Aylward, an epidemiologist who was part of a World Health Organization (WHO)-China mission in February, said China's containment measures can be reduplicated but will require imagination and political courage in an interview with The New York Times.

Trump said on March 18 that two naval hospital ships would be deployed to help support COVID-19 response efforts.

China's answer to a shortage of hospital beds was to build makeshift hospitals. In hardest-hit Wuhan in Hubei Province, central China, two makeshift hospitals were built from scratch in less than 20 days, with a combined 3,000 beds. Gyms, exhibition centers and college dorms were converted into temporary hospitals for patients with mild symptoms to curb family transmission.

Person-to-person transmissions in family clusters made up 78-85 percent of the confirmed cases in China's Guangdong and Sichuan provinces, a report by the WHO-China joint mission on the novel coronavirus disease shows. The first identified community transmission case in New York, an attorney working in the city and living in suburban Westchester County, was linked to at least 28 other coronavirus patients, including his wife, son and daughter.

Testing hurdle

The lack of testing kits and the federal government's resistance to using state labs stalled the U.S.' testing process in February. According to the Covid Tracking Project, an Internet effort to track the number of people tested in the U.S., California and New York, the most proactive states in combating the coronavirus, make up 30 percent of the tests performed across the country, and many states have done only hundreds of tests so far.

In China, manufacturers are able to distribute more than 1.5 million test kits a week, and the Republic of Korea has the capacity to test up to 20,000 people every day.

In Wuhan, 80 percent of patients had mild symptoms and were curable, yet they were as contagious as the severe cases and the critically ill. In a guideline to countries with coronavirus outbreaks, WHO advised governments to "prioritize active, exhaustive case finding and immediate testing and isolation, painstaking contact tracing and rigorous quarantine of close contacts."

Between February 17 and 19, the Wuhan Municipal Government ordered a sweeping effort in the 11-million-people city and identified suspected cases to break the chain of transmission. Aylward called it an "all-of-government, all-of-society approach" that requires the participation of every resident.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has advised people to wash hands, maintain distance and see a doctor if they have the symptoms. Yet based on the Wuhan and larger Chinese experience, more exhaustive investigations of the patient's daily movement and close contacts are necessary to curb transmission.

A mask-wearing New York City subway rider on March 17, the day when confirmed novel coronavirus infection cases exceeded 6,200 in the U.S.(XINHUA)

Financial burden

After the coronavirus outbreak, Chinese authorities announced on January 23 financial support for treating patients. Tests are free of charge, and treatment is covered by medical insurance.

U.S. public health officials rely on people who have shown symptoms and sought medical care to identify patients and their close contacts. But this strategy would work only if people trust the healthcare system and believe they could afford the treatment.

In the U.S., coronavirus treatment might take a toll on average people and prevent them from seeking care. According to the Commonwealth Fund, about one in four U.S. citizens is uninsured or underinsured. Frank Wucinski, a Pennsylvania resident who was evacuated from Wuhan along with his two daughters in February, started a GoFundMe page to raise money to pay for his quarantine bill after going back to the U.S.

"Although I assumed all medical bills from our time in quarantine would be paid by the government, it turns out that I am financially responsible for the six days [my daughter] Annabel and I spent in isolation at the hospital," Wucinski said on the website.

Tian decided to stay in New York, afraid of getting infected in an airport or on the plane. Yet, she is scared of getting sick in the U.S. again after "an infernal experience" seeking medical care when she contracted pneumonia two years ago. Even with her student insurance, she is afraid of being unable to afford her co-payment.

"We should do it in this country as well so you know cost should not be a barrier to seeking care," Kaufman said. "Because you want people to seek care and isolate and not transmit to other people."

(Reporting from New York City)

Copyedited by Madhusudan Chaubey

Comments to

China Focus
Special Reports
About Us
Contact Us
Advertise with Us
Partners:   |   China Today   |   China Hoy   |   China Pictorial   |   People's Daily Online   |   Women of China   |   Xinhua News Agency
China Daily   |   CGTN   |   China Tibet Online   |   China Radio International   |   Global Times   |   Qiushi Journal
Copyright Beijing Review All rights reserved 京ICP备08005356号 京公网安备110102005860