| China |
| Who Is Accountable for Society's Addiction to Scrolling? | |
|
|
![]() (LI SHIGONG)
According to big data service provider QuestMobile, of the time users spent using the top 50 platforms and apps in China, time spent on ByteDance platforms accounted for more than 40 percent in July, a sharp rise of 7.3 percentage points from a year ago. ByteDance is best known for Douyin, the Chinese version of TikTok. However, it is the company's Hongguo Short Drama platform that has become the main focus of discussion due to its high average daily usage time per user. Behind the discussion is a sharper question: When algorithms turn the attention of the entire population into a resource consumed at scale, what accountability do platforms owe society beyond mere compliance? Pan Gaofeng (Xinmin Evening News): Hongguo users spending an average of 150 minutes per day on the platform is a boon for ByteDance, but it is not very reassuring for users or society at large. Those 150 minutes are not abstract; they translate into fewer hours of sleep, thousands fewer steps walked, fewer pages read and more. The cost of this enjoyment is both high and lasting. Prolonged short video and short drama scrolling not only consumes time but also takes a toll on physical and emotional health: sedentary habits, late nights, declining eyesight, fragmented attention, shortened patience and emotional responses driven by push notifications. Adolescents are especially vulnerable. The deeper issue is where algorithms take people. We cannot put all the blame on ByteDance, since this is a widespread problem. The real question is whether refraining from inducing users to stay can become a rule platforms are held to account for, rather than just a piece of advice. Existing regulations already require platforms to offer an option to turn off personalized recommendations and prohibit addictive algorithm models. The problem lies in the gap between rules on paper and products in practice. Can autoplay be off by default? Can the personalized recommendation switch be reachable on the first screen? Can teen mode take effect as soon as the user is identified rather than through parental setup? Should the platform make stopping easier, or make continued scrolling inevitable? More fundamentally, what the algorithms reward requires closer scrutiny and oversight. When completion rates, time spent and frequency of interaction become core metrics, the system naturally favors content that keeps people from stopping the scroll. Algorithm filings with regulators and impact assessments should examine not only whether recommendation models violate regulations but also whether their design encourages excessive screen time and prolonged scrolling. Market competition decides who wins, but not where the winner leads society. Jin Taiyan (Opinion.people.com.cn): Algorithms are not inherently sinful; they are both a mirror and a lever. The mirror reflects people's tendency toward instant gratification, and the lever amplifies it. What matters is not whether algorithms are used but how to set boundaries for them. Autoplay removes the act of pressing play, infinite scrolling erases the natural endpoint, and credits offered by Hongguo convert time spent into rewards. Personal self-discipline is an important factor, but an individual relying on their willpower to fight against a system refined by data, experiments and instant feedback is fighting an unequal battle. Hongguo has discontinued using credits to incentivize viewers and has launched rest reminders, but one case does not equal an industry-wide shift. Whether the whole industry can put on the brakes depends not on one company's conscience but on unified, verifiable rules. Regulators already require algorithm filing, periodic assessment and "convenient" opt-out options. Smooth exits should not be a luxury but a basic bottom line. Regulation must better penetrate the "black box" of algorithms and establish early-warning mechanisms for abnormal user retention. The power of super platforms to dominate hundreds of millions of users' time must have boundaries. When passive addiction becomes daily experience for massive numbers of users, it is no longer a matter of personal time management but a major issue of public governance. Copyedited by G.P. Wilson Comments to yanwei@cicgamericas.com |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|